Last week, this group rocked the Rolling Rtones and delivered.
Tonight they take on Billboard's number ones.
But who will rise to the top?
The pressure is on.
This is American Idol.
Ladies and gentlemen, please welcome your judges,
Randy Rackson, Ellen Degeneres, Kara Dioguardi, and Simon Cowell.
And your host, Ryan Seacrest.
Well, good evening, everyone.
We are coming to live from Los Angeles.
As you know, last week we introduced the top 12 and,
And unfortunately, we had to say goodbye to Lacey Brown.
I know, it's sad, but the show must go on.
Lacey, if you're watching, we wish you the best,
but tonight we move ahead.
Say hi once again to your judges.
Please say hi once again to your judges.
You guys, you look nervous at that point.
Randy, Randy, Randy, so tonight a lot is at stake, right?
It's an important night.
This is a big night, man.
The top 10 make the tour, Ryan,
So whoever doesn't do well could lose out on a giant opportunity and not be on the tour.
That's right.
The Idol Tour this summer is big.
And to get in the tour, you need to vote for your favorite.
That's the name of the game here, is voting. Right, Ellen?
That's right, Ryan, voting.
People watch the show and I think they assume, sometime their favorite is safe.
That's the problem. I think, well, we've seen people go home
that I personally don't think should have gone home.
So, you can't just assume some people is gonna stay, and you've got to vote.
You can't complain that those people are gone. You can't watch the show
and then not vote. Because, you know.
So people have to vote.
That's right.
Kara, let's go back to some of the whining up that Simon has done with you.
- He's given you a hard time about song interpretation. - Yeah
As a songwriter, I just want to get your side of the story.
Why do you think he's giving you such a hard time?
Well, I think he enjoys giving me a hard time actually.
But, I think that, you know, every song has a story.
- Yes, you're right. - It does. It does. Every song does.
That's like a journey, a peak, a high, a valley, a mountain, a lake...
Stop it. And as a performer,
you have to understand that story when you're singing it
- And have a connection to it. - She's got a point.
Yeah.
- I do, don't I? - You do, yeah.
- Thank you. - I apologize.
- You act like that the first time. - You apologize?
Who is this new Simon?
Somebody who's seen the light.
We're seeing very close to your heart with that little v-neck there.
Maybe a little too close.
Ryan, Ryan, stay at your space. OK, OK?
I have a destination.
Don't come close to me today.
Even though you like what I'm wearing, stay where you are.
Whoa, whoa.
In awe, in awe, your highness.
Stay, stay.
Good.
You can lean into me if you want.
Why is tonight... Seriously, why is tonight so important?
Tonight would be rather like if you need 6 numbers on a lottery ticket,
Only getting five if you leave tonight,
Because you don't go on the tour,
so you lose a lot of money.
It would be very damaging to your career.
So it's probably the worst night to go.
Okay.
Way to sum it up.
Let's bring out your top 11.
One more time, ladies and gentlemen, here they are.
Big night. The stakes are high.
We're going to send them off to get ready,
so you guys head backstage and get ready.
Good luck to all of you.
We're counting on you.
You're getting the best of both worlds tonight.
We have a great theme and mentor.
Take a look at this.
This week it's all about being number one.
The contestants were able to choose any song
that appeared at the top of the Billboard Hot 100 list.
I think people will be surprised
saw how old Billboard is.
It's actually 116 yea old, which is amazing.
The Hot 100 is introduced in august of 1958.
The Hot 100 can be any genre, pop, country or r&b.
But they all have something in common.
They're the greatest songs that are out there right now this week.
And here to offer some advice to our idols
is someone who's no stranger to having hit records.
Nobody knows who it is.
I'm really excited to find out.
I'm kind of nervous.
We're kind of starting to get a little anxious now.
Could be anybody.
It's Miley Cyrus.
Hey.
This pop princess only be 17,
But she has a life time of experience, starring in her television show,
Smashing Box Office records and selling over 15 million records.
Having conquered all corners of the entertainment world,
Miley Cyrus is a worldwide sensation.
I'm always the youngest of everything all the time.
It' not about age.
It's always about, I feel it's something like, a trap
I feel like I'm 17, but I have an idea of what I feel.
People don't take you seriously but people take me seriously
because I take myself seriously.
I know what I think is what my heart feels and that's a way it's gonna be.
# going to keep my head held high #
I love being on American Idol.
I'm here to tell them what they can work on.
But I'm not here to tell anyone they are going bad, or whatever.
They wouldn't be here if they couldn't sing.
The talent is not the question.
It's just making them feel comfortable.
Ladies and gentlemen, Miley Cyrus.
Good to have you with us.
Good to be here, Ryan.
So you're sitting wherever you sit.
You get the phone call that you're going to be a mentor on American Idol.
You are 17 years old, as we just mention.
What did you think?
I was a little bit nervous.
You know, I've watched a few of the episodes, and I know how talented they are,
So I was... How am I going to go here and tell them
what they're doing wrong when I don't really see it.
I don't see that there's anything wrong.
But when they're in front of me,
I really just thought they need to connect a little bit more with their fans
because I'm a fan of their music.
So I want them to look at me and sing to me the way they would to another one of their fans.
What did you think in person?
They're amazing.
The voices blew me away.
It actually made me a little bit nervous to watch myself, you know.
That's something I probably do, when I'm on stage, too.
Get nervous or look down, do this or do that.
So it made me look at myself on other performances I've done.
- You don't have to be nervous tonight, but tomorrow night you are performing. - Yes, which is making me nervous.
Yeah, I told Didi just pitch on that might be great.
They'll be looking and saying see now Miley is pitchy.
See? She was yelling us about it.
- That's Jackson's favourite words. - That's right, that's right.
Pitchy is always good.
You know what he says like, maybe you're a little pitchy.
I don't know. I don't know.
Can't avoid pitchy, can I?
Let's get to it.
Here's what happened when Miley met with Lee. Watch this.
I will be singing "The Letter" by the Boxtops.
# give me a ticket for an aeroplane #
# ain't got no time to take no fast train #
Lee, I think, has an amazing voice.
The only thing that is lacking
sometimes is his stage presence.
I don't necessarily go up there and try to put on a personality or a way I am.
I'm not a shy person.
It's just when I'm up there, I'm more focused on the crowd
and the judges and all that than I am just putting on a good performance.
It's a great song.
It's a good choice.
I would just say give them a few notes they wouldn't expect from you.
If he pushes himself, then he'll do fine.
'Cause vocally, he's great.
It's just getting you intrigued and wanting you to hear
Because you don't know what he's going to do with the song.
I'm a little more reserved on stage and I know I ought to push a little harder.
That's what I'm going to do.
Can he pull it off tonight?
Here is the "Letter" from Lee Dewyze.
# give me a ticket for an aeroplane #
# ain't got time to take no fast train #
# oh, the lonely days are gone #
# and I'm not comin'ome #
# and my baby #
# she wrote me a letter #
# I don't care how much money I gotta spend #
# I got to see, got to see my baby once again #
# oh, the lonely days are gone #
# and I'm not comin' home #
# baby, she wrote me a letter #
# when she wrote me a letter #
# said she couldn't live me without no more #
# listen mister, can't you see that I got to get back to my baby once more #
# anyway #
# yeah #
# give me a ticket on an aeroplane #
# I ain't got time to take no fast train #
# oh, the lonely days are gone #
# and I'm comin' home #
# my baby, she wrote me a letter #
# my baby wrote me a letter #
# well, she wrote me #
# my baby wrote me a letter #
# well, he wrote #
# well, she wrote #
# wte me a letter #
# yeah #
Thank you.
Yo...
Lee, Lee, Lee.
So, yo know what's cool, man?
It's cool that you chose this kind of bluesy soul version of the song,
Because when I heard you were choosing it,
I was like, wow, of all the number ones, he chose this?
You know what, dude, you knocked it out of the box.
The way to start off the show, baby.
Okay, so, lee, you know how you have a favorite pen
because it writes just perfectly.
And the ink glides out and it's so great.
And you love that pen more than any... others write
but not as well and it doesn't feel the same.
And all of a sudden it starts running out of ink.
And you say oh, no, I'm losing my favorite pen.
And you light a match under it and you lick it and things like that.
So, my favorite pen is back.
That was fantastic.
You raised the bar for yourself.
I've never heard you sound better, look more comfortable.
You're finally owning the stage.
You can do it even more.
Now that I can see the control you have over your vocals,
but the first time that you stepped on that stage to now,
the progress is tremendous!
Can you feel the difference?
You can, right?
Believe that you're good.
Thank you.
How many number ones could you have chosen?
I mean, there must be thousands.
I'm really, really surprised that you chose that song
Because that, to me, was not a recording performance.
That was you doing something quite corny.
It was.
It actually was.
You sounded good.
You were bouncing around on stage a little bit.
But I think you're kind of missing the point I was trying to say
last week about having a moment.
That doesn't define you as a contemporary recording artist.
So I think that even though missy here loves it,
that's a good reason to do the opposite.
Oh, no. I liked it, too.
Come on.
You are getting better.
Lee dewyze.
We were talking about the show about you relaxing and having fun.
Do you think you were thinking through too much or were you enjoying it?
I was trying not to think at all about it. Just get out here.
And be less stiff and nervous and let loose a little bit.
So, hopefully, I did.
Hopefully it was enough to keep you around.
If you want to vote for Lee...
Lines open at the end of the show and they'll stay open for at least two hours.
Lee, good luck, man.
We're going to leave you for just a second.
On the other side, Paige hits the stage with some Phil Collins live.
Back with you on "Idol."
We're celebrating chart-topping hits tonight.
Here's a cool fact, former Idols have earned 261 Billboard number ones
since the show started back in 2002.
Hoping to add to that was Paige who siting here,
Paige actually stealing rings from the audience.
She gave it to me.
Hold that up, I think someone at the judge's table is in the market for one of those.
She gave it to me.
Simon, Simon, this is what it looks like.
- Did he say something? - All right.
One of the big shoes for you was she gaved earlier.
You were concerned about the heel. How would you do?
It is the biggest, tallest, longest heel I've ever worn in my life,
so I'm praying that I don't fall.
Did you walk around a little bit before the show?
Yeah, I had to, you know, break it in a little bit, so...
How was the atmosphere different for you contests the preparing?(TBD)
'Cause this is an important week. - The atmosphereit has changed quite a bit.
It's more serious, more quiet back there, too.
A lot of thinking going on.
It's a big week.
People becoming selfish.
They want their spot, right.
Let's take a look at your session with Miley. Watch.
Hi, Miley.
Nice to meet you.
I was kind of star-struck. You know, she's been on tour, platinum albums.
She spotted one hundred times of more experience on stage.
Her age makes no difference at all.
What song are you going to sing?
"Against All Odds" by Phil Collins.
First of all, she's really beautiful.
And she has a great voice.
Your voice is just as powerful when you sing really soft
as when you start to belt it out.
And not many people really have that.
The only thing is when you're not super soft and you're not loud,
you can get a little bit pitchy.
I was singing it in my head the whole time, and it was like pitchy, pitchy...
She nailed me for it.
So go Miley.
I know she was sick last week.
So, better... but it's just her voice's ill.
Thank you so much for singing that for me.
- It was really nice to meet you. - Thank you so much, Miley.
I think she will do amazing on the show.
I think as long as she watches her pitch, she'll do really great.
Let's see if Miley's prediction wins through.
Here's Phil Collins' 1984 hit "Against All Odds" by Paige Miles.
# how can I just let you walk away #
# just let you leave without a trace #
# when I stand here taking every breath with you #
# ooh #
# you're the only one #
# who really knew me at all #
# so take a look at me now #
# because there's just an empty space #
# and there's nothing left here to remind me #
# just the memory of your face #
# I wish I could just make you turn around #
# turn around and see me cry #
# there's so much I need to say to you #
# so many reasons why #
# you're the only one #
# who really knew me at all #
# so take a look at me now #
# because there's just an empty space #
# and there's nothing left here to remind me #
# just the memory of your face #
# take a good look at me now #
# 'cause I'll still be standing here #
# and you coming back to me is against all odds #
# it's the chance I've got to take #
# ooh, take a look at me now #
# ooh, ooh #
Hi, how are you?
Good. how are you?
Yo, man, yo, wow.
Really, honestly, I don't know if your voice is back or whatever's happening,
but that was honestly terrible.
It was terrible.
Really, honestly, it was really... and I don't know... I don't even know.
I mean, whoa, there was nothing about it that was great.
The pitch was all over the place.
Nothing came together at all.
I don't know.
And I know you're probably better.
So maybe you don't have your voice back.
I don't know, man, but it was terrible.
- E? - I'm going to start with the positive.
You didn't fall down, and that's a good thing, right?
That's an accomplishment.
Those are high, high heels.
I know.
I'm wearing them right now.
Listen, you look stunning.
You've never looked better.
Your hair looks great.
You look beautiful.
And I am now going to turn over the music critique to Kara and Simon.
Paige, somewhere along the line I think you stopped competing
and you stopped listening to what we were saying,
because, you know, that's a really big song.
You took on the Mariah version
and if you're going to take that on, it better be spectacular.
And I have to say, and I'm sorry to say it,
it was the worst vocal that I've ever heard from you and possibly of the season.
How do you... Paige, how do you think you did?
Um, well, I mean, I definitely struggleded with the song.
My pitch was all over the place.
I did have trouble finding myself in it, but I had, you know, fun doing it.
I really connect to the song,
but I definitely did struggle with my pitch, so, definitely definitely.
All right. So we are on the same page here,
because to be honest with you,
it was like there were five of you singing that song,
and it got progressively worse, each one.
It was just all over the place.
And the awful thing was that I knew the point you knew as well.
And I think you're going to be
in serious, serious trouble tonight, sweetheart, I really do.
And I think what Kara said is right.
It's like you stopped competing and you stopped believing in yourself.
And it's such a shame.
Because you were so good weeks ago.
But that song I think has just killed you.
I do.
I just want to give you a second to respond to the competitive component.
You still are in this to win it. You still...
Definitely, yeah.
I'm Definitely still in it to win it.
I've been struggling with song choice badly.
I've been, you know, really trying to find that song
that, you know, that I can really sink my teeth into
and, you know, it was hard for me, so it definitely was.
Moments like this are tough.
But if you've been watching Paige and you've become a fan
and you want to keep her around, the phone number is...
Calls are toll-free from landlines and standard rates apply.
- Paige thank you very much. - Thank you very much.
We'll be back wit you live when Tim takes on Queen next.
Back on "Idol" live tonight.
The top 11 taking on Billboard number ones under the tutelage of Miley Cyrus.
Here's a look at a time with Tim and his Queen song. Roll the tape.
I'm singing the song "Crazy Little Thing Called Loved."
Tim has gotten bad reviews because, you know, of not having a lot of personality
or for being a little bit boring.
It's not the personality that he's lacking.
It's just adding risk and switch it up somehow.
# crazy little thing called love #
You know what?
Let me give you a hug.
'Cause I don't think you're boring at all.
I think you're great.
Hearing Miley says that means a lot just having that encouragement
from someone who has been so successful.
I'm all for pushing, you know, the limit. So That's the only thing I would say.
It's just work it out towards the end, belt it, do something cool and different.
You've got a cool thing that you've got confidence.
So I would give you two thumbs up.
I think you rock.
Thank you.
I'm going to loosen up.
I'm going to put down the guitar, move around the stage, have a lot of fun with it.
So, you know, it's going to be a good performance.
Performing "Crazy Little Thing Called Coved," let's hear for Tim Urban.
# this thing called love #
# I just can't handle it #
# this thing called love #
# I must get around to it #
# I ain't ready #
# crazy little thing called love #
# this thing called love #
# it cries #
# in a cradle all night #
# it swings #
# it jives #
# it shakes all over like a jellyfish #
# I kinda like it #
# crazy little thing called love #
# well,there goes my baby #
# she knows how to rock 'n' roll #
# she drives me crazy #
# she gives me hot and cold fever #
# then leaves me in a cool, cool sweat #
# gotta be cool, relax #
# get hip #
# get on my tracks #
# take a backseat #
# hitch-hike #
# take a long, long ride on a motor bike #
# 'til I'm ready #
# crazy little thing called love #
# this thing called love #
# I just can't handle it #
# this thing called love #
# I must get around to it #
# I ain't ready #
# this crazy little thing called love #
# crazy little thing called love #
Yo, Tim, dog, did you have a good time, you had a good time, righ?
yeah, I had a great time.
Wow, look, I mean, you know,
what's hard for me, this is a singing competition, right.
We're supposed to find the best that we can find
and every time you guys hit the stage,
you're supposed to be showing up like just wowing us
and we should be going like, oh, my god, he's so dope.
The dopest thing you did was the slide, dude.
The vocals were so boring.
I was like what show is this?
It was like karaoke, it was like bad karaoke.
I don't know, I don't know.
See, that's the thing.
You have huge fans.
You have a lot of fans who absolutely love you.
But it really... it felt like to me it was an audition for "High School Musical."
I don't know what they're on, 6 or 7 now.
- But Vanessa and Troy went to college, I know that. - 17.
I know that. But...
I felt like it was just corny.
It was just pushed too hard.
And there's a large group of people that will love that performance.
But. See? And then there's me.
And I just... you know, I just didn't... I didn't get it.
Sorry. Sorry.
Ellen hit the nail on the hat. It was Zac Efron and hairspray.
I don't know what... you know.
And little girls would love that. But...
You took the song, you didn't do much with it,
you didn't change up the melodys.
And, you know, grabbing at the audience like this.
You're not at that place yet.
You're not established.
You don't... you know, you haven't sold
hundreds millions of records.
So you acted like you were...
already made it and you haven't.
You have a lot of work to do.
I love you, Tim!
I don't think the sliding around was the problem,
because I think it distracted from the song,
so I kind of understand why you did that.
It's true.
I... the problem was, is that it was completely and utterly pointless and silly.
I'm actually surprised that song was a number one record.
And again, with all the thousands of songs, thousands of songs you could have chosen,
you're not actually, again, taking part in this, you know?
You're just there singing and dancing.
You've got zero chance of winning just now.
You have, unless you actually start to take some proper singing lessons,
get your act together, and like I said before,
actually try and become somebody who is contemporary and relevant.
So this is two weeks, silly, silly song choices.
Now that the wind is knocked out of you,
So tell us a little bit about why you decided to do that song that way?
I picked such slow songs up to this point and very relaxed.
I really hadn't done anything as far as moving around,
and I just wanted to have some fun.
I wanted to move around.
I like the song.
So I just picked a song I could have some fun with.
You guys are the judge at home.
You dial for Tim.
Thank you, Tim.
I've seen Randy slide.
After this, we're back with Aerosmith and Janis Joplin coming to you from Aaron and Crystal.
Hang tight.
Thank you for choosing "American Idol" this evening.
We are live here with Aaron, Aaron Kelly, ladies and gentlemen.
Now, I understand you're having a little trouble with your voice.
What's going on?
Um, just recently, you know, everybody's been getting laryngitis.
I pick up laryngitis and just hopefully it doesn't affect anything tonight.
Laryngitis and tonsillitis?
- That's awesome. - Two for one.
Let me see this for a second.
I'm not going to make you answer any questions by talking.
We'll just... Be right with you.
Any questions?
I may have just a little crush on Miley.
Just a little.
What's up?
Miley. Nice to meet you. my very first audition,
I sang "The Climb," Which was a Miley Cyrus song
and I was thinking I wonder if Miley saw it.
I wonder what she thought about it.
I saw you sing "The Climb."
It was really great.
To hear that from somebody
you are a fan of, you know, it just brightens your day.
Tonight I'm going to sing AeroSmith's "I don't Want to Miss a Thing."
I made a face because I didn't realize how good he was.
- Yeah. That was awesome. - Thank you.
You have literally and incredible voice.
I was really impressed.
I think he's really good.
Can I give you a hug?
- Yes, you can give me a hug. - Thank you, Miley, for your advice and I love you.
With "I don't Want to Miss a Thing,"
Here is our youngest contestant, Aaron Kelly.
Let's see how he does.
# I could stay awake just to hear you breathing #
# watch you smile while y're sleeping #
# while you're far away and dreaming #
# I could spend my life in this sweet surrender #
# I could stay lost in this moment forever #
# every moment spent with you #
# is a moment I treasure #
# I don't want to close my eyes #
# don't wanna fall asleep #
# 'cause I'd miss you #
# and I don't want to miss a thing #
# even when I dream of you #
# the sweetest dream will never do #
# I'd still miss you #
# and I don't want to miss a thing #
# I just wanna hold you close #
# feel your heart be close to mine #
# and stay lost in this moment #
# through all the rest of time #
# I don't wanna close my eyes #
# I don't wanna fall asleep #
# 'cause I'd miss you #
# and I don't wanna miss a thing #
All right, check it out,check it out
So, listen,man, it wasn't a perfect performance.
There were a couple of pitch things,
that one high note in the break was a little under,
but I knew you were a little under the weather with your voice.
Let me tell you something, thank god you came on the stage
and you started singing.
The two before you, I was like what's going on tonight?
So listen, I know you've got a cold, tonsillitis, whatever, but I like you.
You're very talented and I love the way you sang that first verse.
Dude, you took it out, I'm a fan!
I'm a fan!
First of all, that was perfect song choice for you,
and I could tell you were sick because every single time you sing,
I go home and watch the the show after this, you're pretty much always pitch perfect.
You have such an amazing voice.
And you're, what, in third grade or something.
I mean,you really... I see your career already.
I mean, you are so good.
You are so good.
That was amazing.
Liked it.
Ellen said it.
Best song choice of the night. Best.
And maybe one week you were off,
but week to week, you really know how to pick a song that
accentuates the strength in your voice and shows consistency
because you do have that country twang,
and I can hear it week to week.
I'm not going to beat you up on the vocal
because it wasn't perfect and we know why.
I am going to say more stage presence from you.
I want to see it. But overall, good attempt due to the circumstances.
- Good stuff. - Thank you.
Look, it was very brave.
You've got tonsillitis, laryngitis, whatever you've got.
You know, you're a little trier, aren't you?
If I had any criticism, I would say that I think for your age,
you're making yourself old-fashioned.
It's true. Zero chance you are going to go home.
And I think you should give Miley another hug.
All right. If you want to vote for David Archaletta here...
Good work, man. Thank you very much.
Let's keep it going with Crystal.
What song are you singing?
"Me and Bobby Mcgee."
I love that song. I think it has so much personality.
I really like what she did with it.
I think it was a little bit different.
There were times when she sang those high notes
that she got almost gospel and I really love that sound.
I think it's beautiful. I think she could do it more.
I really like when you go higher.
I would almost showcase that a little more.
Maybe you can try it. I think she could push herself a little more.
Your voice sounds great.
I like the way it sounded but I'm worried about hitting those big notes.
I don't know if I can do it.
I really think you can. I think that song is really great.
So while you're here, I have powerful, beautiful women sign my guitars.
I'm collecting signatures on my guitar,
and today Miley signed it, so got one more watch.
You're talented and so beautiful. Don't be afraid.
Nice to see you. Good job.
Thanks.
Will she apply Miley's advice on stage?
With Janis Joplin's "Me and Bobby Mcgee," Here's Crystal Bowersox.
# busted flat in baton rouge #
# waiting for a train #
# feelin' near as faded as my jeans #
# bobby thumbed a diesel down #
# just before it rained #
# rode us all the way to new orleans #
# freedom's just another word for nothing left to lose #
# nothing don't mean nothing, hon, if it ain't free #
# yeah, and if feelin' goo was easy, lord #
# bobby sang the blues #
# feelin' good was good enough for me #
# good enough for me and my bobby mCgee #
# la, la, la, la, la #
# bobby mCgee, yeah #
# da nah da nah da nah #
# nah, nah, nah #
# hey, hey, hey #
# bobby mCgee #
# I called him my lover #
# called him my friend #
# called him my lover #
# did the best I can now #
# come on bobby now #
# bob mCgee #
# no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no #
# hey, hey, hey, yeah #
# bobby mCgee #
# yeah #
Yo, yo, listen, check this out, America, the show is called "American Idol."
That's what's called being a star and an adult singer right there.
That's the way you do it. You come out here.
You sing what is in your heart.
People have been comparing you to Janis,
she is a amazing great, dude, that's what it's about.
I'm so happy now. This is what it's about.
- She's what it'about. - Thank you.
I was driving the other day and this song came on the radio
and I thought of you immediately.
She should sing that song. I was so happy to hear that.
Look, there's nothing wrong with that performance.
You've got an amazing voice. You're consistently great.
The only thing, and I said it last week,
we're missing a bit of personality which we saw last week.
I feel like there's a little bit of something
between you and us and the audience.
I would love to see a little more... Even when people are going crazy,
you're kind of standing there and you're kind of stoic.
I'm sure it's nerves or whatever. You're probably shy.
But a little more connection, a little more like take it in.
These people love you. Take it all in and respond.
- I have big plans for next week. - I think people want to share that with you.
I want to see that you're receiving it. Because people are sending you a lot of love. And I don't see...
- I'm doing it. I am. I really am. - Good, good. Give it back. Keep going
It's interesting you bring that point up.
Coz' I heard you last week say something that I've got a lot on my mind.
I'm thinking about this, I'm thinking about that. Were you thinking about anything tonight during that performance?
- I let go. - You did, I did feel more. I saw you smiling.
I saw you moving a little more.
I know what you're saying, Ellen.
I think, too, would you ever consider putting the guitar down for a performance?
I just told Ellen that I have big plans for next week. We'll see.
I'm liking this, because I think you may get more into it and free yourself
And I want to see you let go completely, even more than this week.
All right. Thank you.
OK, Well, I wouldn't change anything.
Up until now, we have listened to a karaoke competition, and somebody comes on,
I've heard Pink sing that version of the song,
Which is one of the best versions I've ever heard,
And that was as good as that in my opinion.
You know, Randy's right. This is about finding a recording artist.
I actually have seen your progress over the last couple of weeks.
You're doing your own thing.
You're not sliding all over the stage,
Jumping into the crowd like we've seen before, gimmicky.
You just took a song, nailed it, and your only gimmick is a carpet.
Crystal Bowersox. Simon mentioned the magic carpet square here.
- Let's sit. - All right, let's make a night of it.
- Let's order some chiken and hang out. - It's plush.
This makes you feel more comfortable?
Yeah. It's homey. It's like... you know. It's just... The stage is cold and gray. And this is pretty.
You warmed it up. If you want to vote for Crystal...
Lines open at the end of the show.
Thank you very much, Crystal, for this rest time. This is nice.
Thank you, Ryan.
On the other side, big Mike channels his romantic side.
Hang on for that.
Welcome back to "American idol."
You stand up like I'm going to get excited about that sign.
Are you kidding? Glad to have you two with us with this Simon love.
The top 11 taking on Billboard's number ones.
We have Mike's time with Miley. Take a look at this.
What's up? You're already my favorite.
This is the biggest hug I've ever gotten.
Everyone else is gonna afraid to touch me again.
- I've heard you've been trashing everybody all day. So... - Oh yeah, I'm totally evil.
Miley was cool. Miley was all of straight. She was like a little sister to me.
# when a man loves a woman #
I'm falling in love with you.
# can't keep his mind on nothing else #
I think his voice is absolutely incredible. He sang that song to me the entire way.
I could't do that. It's very nerve-wracking to stare at someone and sing to them.
Eye contact is a big deal. And Looking at her made it easy.
- She has really kind eyes. - I'm in love with you.
Mike has such personality to him.
I think that will take him a really long way. I had nothing bad to say.
With tonight's performance, I really really hope to speak to the lovers out there.
You know the song really speaks to men. It really speaks to women.
We can all use a little love in our lives.
Here is a classic from our Casanova,
"When a Man Loves a Woman," Here's Michael Lynche.
# when a man loves a woman #
# can't keep his mind on nothing else #
# he'll trade the whole world for the good thing he's found #
# if she is bad he can't see it #
# she can do no wrong #
# he'll turn his back on his best friend #
# if he puts her down #
# oh, when a man loves a woman #
# I'd give everything, everything I have #
# I'm tryin' to hold on to your precious love #
# ooh, baby, please don't treat me bad #
# when a man loves, loves, loves his woman #
# sleep out in the pouring rain #
# if she says that's the way it ought to be #
# oh, yeah #
# when a man loves, loves a woman #
# I know exactly how he feels #
# 'cause baby, baby, baby #
# you're my world #
Yo Mike. Check it out, baby. Check it out.
Listen, I don't know if it was the perfect song choice,
I don't know if it was the best vocal yet.
You know what I loved, man. It was the same thing Simon said about Crystal.
Listen, you know who you are. You're this R & B soul dude.
The best thing you can do on this show is sing and I don't know
what out of who you are and be that every time you hit that stage.
That's what you did today. I loved it.
I did feel like it was sort of a safe choice.
It was like you know, driving the speed limit.
It was fine and you got there and you have an amazing tone.
You have a great, great voice. And this woman loves that man.
Mike, you know I love you.
You know, technically, it was really good. You hit all the notes.
But I just felt it was a bit boring and loungy at times. I'm sorry.
And overindulgent. Too many riffs,
And I lost my connection with you performing it.
I'm sorry. But you know I still love you.
I kind of know what you're saying.
It's like you want one scoop of ice cream and you got 11.
It was just almost too much. I think if I advised you about choosing that song,
No disrespect, I would have taken all this lot off the stage.
I would have just had you, piano, very simple,
Because the truth is, Michael, is that this audition could have
taken place 30 years ago, 20 years ago, 10 years ago.
It's trying to make an old-fashioned song like that an old school song relevant.
And actually what Kara said was kind of right.
You made it very loungy.
So you've got to work this out... The good news is that you've got tons of charisma.
You've actually got a very, very good voice and people like you.
And I'm glad we have the choice, the chance this week to have a conversation
This week without any irritating interruptions.
Thank you for that, Ryan.
Looking out for yourself.
- The idea, you wanted to make that sexy, Rickey told me. -Not sexy.
- Just heavy. - That's what you said? Heavy, Ok.
He said sexy. I'm just saying, he's confused
For Michael, you can dial...
Michael, thank you very much, man
When build your band tonight here continues, Andrew does Motown.
Don't miss it.
The top 11 are taking the stage this evening.
Remember, your votes will ensure your favorite is part of this summer's tour.
There's only room for 10. Will that include Andrew?
- Hello. Hey, what's up? - Andrew.
Miley. Nice to meet you.
What song are you singing, first of all?
- Oh, Marvin Gaye, "I heard it through the grapevine." - Awesome.
Today I met Miley Cyrus. It was cool to meet someone on that level.
I feel a little worried about lyrics.
I kind of stumbled on my lyrics, and I was like, oh, my god.
Why did you do that? I was really trying to impress her.
So I forgot some of the lyrics
And she suggested that I put down the guitar.
I feel like you could do it by just like singing and working the crowd.
I think the chicks would dig it. I made him lose his guitar
Because it just blocked him and it became really stiff.
# I heard it through the grapevine #
I'm taking a risk by putting the guitar down.
- So I hope American enjoys it. - Thank you so much.
- Learn on your word. - I know, I know.
Does he have his lyrics together tonight?
Here's Marvin Gaye's "I Heard It Through The Grapevine," Andrew Garcia.
# I'm just about to lose my mind #
# I bet you're wonderin' how I knew #
# about your plans to make me blue #
# with some other guy you knew before #
# between the two of us guys #
# you know I loved you more #
# it took me by surprise, I must say #
# how I found out yesterday #
# don't you know that I heard it through the grapevine #
# not much longer would you be mine #
# oh, I heard it through the grapevine #
# ooh, and I'm just about to lose my mind #
# honey, honey, yeah #
# heard it through the grapevine #
# I know a man ain't supposed to cry #
# but these tears I can't hold inside #
# losin' you would end my life, you see #
# 'cause you mean that much to me #
# you could have told me yourself #
# that you loved someone else #
# instead I heard it through the grapevine #
# not much longer would you be mine #
# oh, I heard it through the grapevine #
# oh, and I'm just about to lose my mind #
# honey, honey, yeah #
# don't you know that I heard it #
# heard it #
# heard it through the grape #
# vine #
- Yo, Andrew. - What's up, Randy?
Oh, dog, man. Dog, man, it wasn't good, man. For me it wasn't good.
I mean, listen, it was the wrong song choice
Because this is not the kind of vocal that you are,
You know what I'm saying?
Singing these kind of... It just didn't work, dude.
- It wasn't good. It wasn't good. - All right, I'm sorry, man
- You know how much I love you, right? I love you. - I love you, too.
And I know you have a lot of fans and I hope they vote for you,
Because that was not enough to get a whole bunch of people on board
That are kind of teetering right now.
It just wasn't fantastic. Just not a good song choice at all.
But I love you and I hope people vote for you.
I love you, too, Ellen. I love you, too.
I love you, Randy. I love all you guys.
- Kara. - Look, Andrew, I feel bad for you, I do.
You're chasing that moment,
which was brilliant, and I think it's playing with your head.
I think it's messing with you. And you don't know what to do up there.
You're really confused.
And that's what I'm getting from you.
Because these motions with your hands,
It was like someone was moving you like a puppet.
It didn't feel like Andrew. I don't know who that was.
That's not you. You're more swag, you move like this
And I don't know what to do with you other than you go back to that moment where you
did "Straight up" and look at what you did, because you have... You are far from that.
And I feel sick saying that to you, but it's the truth.
Maybe we just overrated that moment in hindsight.
No, no, it was brilliant.
It wasn't like listening to Beethoven for the first time.
It was a cute version of a Paula song.
You've had enough time to sort yourself out.
I think Miley gave you good advice to lose the guitar
Because you were hiding behind it.
The problem right now with that was the arrangement was horrific.
You sucked the soul out of that song.
You did. Sucked it out and tortured it
and ruined one of the great pop songs of all time, and in
The mean... At the same time, you made yourself really, really corny.
And, you know, you've got the best opportunity in the world right now,
Which is you're in front of tens of millions of people week after week.
Any good artist within seven days with that broad amount of choice
should be able to nail and choose a great song, and
that should show that you don't know who you are as an artist.
Is there any truth to that?
I know who I am. It's all good.
- I know who I am. - So what was the plan with that song? - Just to have fun.
And before these, the fans, for everybody who voted for me, my family, my friends
All right. You can vote if he deserves to make it through.
Don't vote until the end of the show.
Thank you, Andrew. Thanks a lot, man.
- Thanks, Ryan. - Up next, one 17-year-old guides another.
Miley meets Katie after the break.
Back with you live on American Idol Tonight.
The number one show is taking on number one hits from the Billboard charts.
Next up we've got high school student Katie meeting Miley. Take a look at this.
- Hi, Katie. - Hi, Miley. Nice to meet you.
What song are you singing?
"Big Girls Don't Cry" By Fergie.
Working with Miley today was great.
It was great to get feedback
from somebody who's in the business and who's also my age.
How do you deal with like people who are negative
or different comments you might get?
Remember who you are as a musician and what you love about music.
I've really listened to the judges
and how they've said that they want me to be who I am.
I think just edge it up and show who you are as an artist.
If Katie shows confidence on the stage just by, you know, really taking the song and
making it her own, I think she'll do great.
- Thank you so much. Nice to meet you. - Good choice.
Miley kind of boosted my confidence.
I'll be able to go out there and have that confidence and
hopefully it will shine through in my performance.
We shall see. Here's Fergie's Number One hit
"Big Girls Don't Cry" from Katie Stevens.
# da, da, da #
# the path that I'm walkin' #
# I must go alone #
# I must take the baby steps #
# 'til I'm full grown #
# full grown #
# fairytales don't always have a happy ending, do they #
# and I foresee the dark ahead if I say #
# I hope you you know #
# I hope you know #
# that this has nothing to do with you #
# it's personal #
# myself and I #
# we've got some straightening out to do #
# and I'm gonna miss you like a child misses their blanket #
# but I've got to get a move on with my life #
# it's time to be a big girl now #
# and big girls don't cry #
# like a little school mate in the schoolyard #
# will play jacks and Uno cards #
# I'll be your best friend and you'll be my valentine #
# I hope you know #
# that this has nothing to do with you #
# it's time to be a big girl now #
# and big girls don't cry #
Well, listen, I think... I don't know if it was your best
performance, but what I love about what you did,
is that you listened... Well, it was a little sharp, a little pitchy, all over the place, here and there.
But what you did that was cool was that
you actually listened to us, you picked a younger song.
And you know, even the outfit is all younger. I... I'm likng that you're listening.
I like that.
I actually... I think it was your best performance so far.
I thought you sounded great. And you look great.
And you're evolving and changing,
and you're like the Dakota Fanning of American Idol. You... you just...
- I liked it a lot. - So, Simon, do you still think she's country?
Do you have a point to make?
Yes, I do, actually. This is the lane for you. Pop with R&B leanings.
'Cause today you actually moved like you felt the song.
It was a different Katie.
This is where you belong.
This is your vibe. Now, hold on.
You've still got mad pitch issues, but this is where you belong.
These types of songs.
- Right, Randy? - Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Nice.
- Simon? - I think you meeting
Miley Cyrus was probably the best thing
that could ever happen to you.
I mean, seriously, because, you know,
similar age, had a big career.
The way you look tonight compared to
sort of the pageant horror outfit we saw weeks ago,
I mean, it's chalk and cheese.
Do I, however, believe that you are believable in this area?
I'm still not sure.
I would still go with the advice I gave you before,
because I think you could find a more loyal market to you.
I think you're competing right now in a very, very difficult place,
and I don't think it's in your head to be what you want to be.
So I still think I'm right and this one is wrong.
But having said, it was a good performance.
Katie Stevens.
That's a desire when he said he was right.
- Were you comfortable with that song? - I was.
I had a lot of fun, so I hope that shows,
'cause that was a blast.
So it was good meeting Miley.
It was. I loved meeting Miley.
You guys should hang out. She's over there.
- Tisha give her permission hanging out. - Yeah, let's hang out.
Don't vote until the end of the show.
Katie, thank you very much. Good luck.
- Thank you. - You're welcome.
After this, a rocker takes on '80s anthem. Casey is next.
Welcome back. American Idol. We are live here in Hollywood.
Casey James is up in just a second.
So just thinking about last week,
I remember the judges saying, and it was Simon saying
you've got to push yourself this week, right?
- Yeah, he did. - So, what you gonna do to push yourself, Casey?
It made me realize I've got like 10, 11 years of
playing in a very small place.
I kind of just tend to be stagnant, you know.
So, you know, realizing what's going on here,
I need to get around a little bit and make it more fun.
How did it go earlier today, rehearsal?
It was great.
- You mean you really feel like you own this song. - I hope so.
Okay. It's coming up. Just a second.
He's doing "The Power Of Love" in a moment.
First here's a look at Casey's time with Miley.
Miley. Good to see you.
I'm a big fan of your Dad's.
Oh, oh, oh.
Not me, but my dad.
Thank you.
This week I'm going to be playing Huey Lewis, "The Power Of Love".
I like the lyrics.
I like the idea of the song.
I like the power of it.
I like the passion.
Well, you rock.
I don't have anything crazy to say, but when I'm on stage,
I always try to make eye contact with the like first few people
that are in the front row.
So you do that, you know, because you and I made eye contact at one point,
it makes your song sounds personal.
It's a funny thing she brought that up.
Because this week I was really going to focus on that,
make the crowd a part of the song.
You have no idea when I'm on tour
how much that means to people.
I have, you know, girls and boys when I look at them,
they freak out and they look at each other and like it's such a moment.
If he does that, he brings personality to it,
I think he'll do great.
From "Back To The Future," "The Power Of Love",
Casey James.
# the power of love is a curious thing #
# make one man weep, make another man sing #
# change a hawk to a little white dove #
# more than a feeling #
# that's the power of love #
# don't take money #
# don't take fame #
# don't need no credit card to ride this train #
# strong and it's sudden #
# and it's cruel sometimes #
# but it just might change your life #
# that's the power of love #
# tougher than diamonds #
# rich like cream #
# stronger and harder than a bad girl's dream #
# mad a bad one good #
# make a wrong one right #
# power of love will keep you home at night #
# don't take money #
# don't need fame #
# you don't need no credit card to ride this train #
# it's strong and it's sudden #
# and it's cruel sometimes #
# it might just change your life #
# yeah, yeah, yeah #
# don't take money #
# don't take fame #
# you don't need no credit card to ride this train #
# strong and it's sudden #
# and it's cruel sometimes #
# but it might just change your life #
# that's the power of love #
Yo, yo, man, listen, you know what?
You know I'm a fan of yours,
and I love you playing the guitar.
I think you're probably the best musician guitar player
we've ever had on the air.
I tell you what.
I wasn't a fan of the song choice,
but I got to tell you something, I've got give you props.
You definitely did it well.
I believed it. I believed it.
Thank you.
Same here. I was not a fan of the song choice.
I think there was a much better song.
But that being said, I think it was the best vocal of the night.
I thought you sounded great.
You just found another level.
I mean, with the right songs,
if you had 10 hit songs,
you're just ready to make an album.
You're just there. It's all there.
Everything.
It just gets better and better and better.
You're in a zone now.
You're in a zone. Stay in it.
Simon?
Look, Casey, I promise you this is not personal,
but I don't know what you're listening to, Kara.
I genuinely don't.
Because that song was old-fashioned 25 years ago when it came out.
He made it current.
He didn't make it current.
- He did an identical version to the Huey Lewis version. - No.
It was like watching and listening to an '80s cover band.
There was no effort, no originality.
Nothing different.
Maybe it's just me.
- Maybe it's you. - Maybe it's because I'm English.
Maybe it's you.
That is true.
How can you guys be hearing two different songs in the same song?
We don't agree on a lot of things.
He did it great. It was cool.
- Does he deserve to advance? - Yes, yes.
There you go.
That's the decision you've got to make America.
For Casey...
Lines open at the end of the show.
They stay open for at least two hours.
- Casey, thank you very much, man. - Thank you.
Last week this girl tapped into her dark side.
What will she do tonight? Didi takes the stage, next tense.
We're back on American Idol.
You're pitchy, dog, you're pitchy.
Here's the advice Miley gave to our waitress, Didi.
Watch this.
# even better #
# now that we're through #
Didi sang "You're No Good"
I like the vibrato in her voice.
I think it's really a good song for her,
because she's okay with that.
I felt a little bit nervous.
Because the song is kind of a challenge.
I'm challenging myself.
Do you get nervous right before you go on stage every time?
Anyone that tells you that
they're not nervous at all when they're going on a stage,
There has to be a little bit.
That's what drives you.
It made me feel better that Miley said she gets nervous, too.
I know it's like a normal thing. It's not just me who like freaks out.
Don't let it take over. You're good. You're good to go.
I think just even go bigger
and beyond with that performance that you just did. I love it.
I need to not be nervous
'cause I think it really affects my performances.
It's no good.
I'm going to sing the song to my nerves tonight.
The pressure is on with Linda Ronstadt's 1974 hit
"You're No Good," Here's Didi Benimi, Benami, sorry.
# feeling better now that we're through #
# feeling better 'cause I'm over you #
# I learned my lesson, it left a scar #
# now I see you really are #
# you're no good, you're no good, you're no good #
# baby you're no good #
# I'm gonna say it again #
# you're no good, you're no good, you're no good #
# baby, you're no good #
# I broke a heart that's gentle and true #
# well I broke a heart over someone like you #
# I'll beg his forgiveness on bended knee #
# I wouldn't blame him if he 'rno good,
# you're no good, you're no good #
# baby, you're no good #
# I'm gonna say it again #
# you're no good, you're no good, you're no good #
# baby, you're no good #
# well, I'm tellin' you, baby, #
# forget about you baby, 'cause I'm leavin' to stay #
# you're no good, you're no good, you're no good #
# baby, you're no good #
# mmm, tell you again #
# you're no good, you're no good, you're no good #
# baby, you're no good #
Yo, listen, I loved the idea of it, the outfit, the
whole thing, the man playing the bass. I loved that.
Just the pitches were a little... Very pitchy all over the place.
It never quite caught.
- You never quite hit the pitch right. - Okay.
Didi, I don't get the song choices tonight.
I really don't.
I mean, I didn't think it was the right song choice for you.
And I do love your voice. And so you're not no good, you're good.
- But I just didn't get that song choice. - Okay.
- Kara? - I loved it!
Didi, I thought like you were playing a character.
It felt very dramatic, almost,
like you were, you know, very slinky and moving in a way.
It didn't feel like it was you.
It felt like you were trying to be something that you aren't.
And it just left me confused.
- Simon? - There's a certain irony, you screeching out
you're no good, you're no good, you're no good over and over again, 'cause...
Oh, give me a break! Come on. You know, it's true.
It's like... It was like a musical.
It was like a part, the bad part of the musical,
You know, just before the interval.
And that's what it came over,
you know, the kind of like the playing off with the bass player
and all that kind of stuff and it didn't sound like it was you.
It was something like... You sounded... You'd rehearsed
and learned and you actually sounded like Lacey, who left last week,
you know when she was trying to play a part.
You suddenly filled that role.
It sucked the life out of you a bit.
- You say whatever you like, darling. - Okay.
I don't want to be pigeon-holed into one little
category because I have... I'm diverse.
I have lots of different sides
and I wanted to show a different side tonight.
I guess you're saying I was pitchy, whatever.
But, you know, I just wanted to do something different and,
you know, have fun on stage and, so, I had a good time.
So does she get another shot? That's your decision to make.
She took a risk tonight. What do you do?
- Didi, thank you very much. - Thank you.
Appreciate it.
When we come back... Siobhan closes the show with Stevie.
It is Idol. It is live.
One more for you tonight, ladies and gentlemen.
Here's what happened when Siobhan met up with Miley. Take a look.
- I'm Miley. - Pleasure to meet you.
Nice meeting you, too.
I'm really excited to hear your song.
- What are you singing? - I'm singing "Superstition" By Stevie Wonder.
- So excited. I love your voice. - Thank you.
Siobhan stuck out to me.
She's got something interesting about her.
# there is superstition #
Oh man, you know, I rocked out to meet Miley Cyrus,
she's younger than me, but she's such a big star.
Your voice has such like a
swagger to it and I think if you
just bring the swag that you
have in your voice to the stage,
you're good to go.
I think it's really cool that
she said my voice has swagger.
I just like that you're so
different and you're so who you are
and your voice says that.
I've been different my whole life
and the fact that that's being noticed by people like her
gives me more confidence to go
out on stage and not be afraid
to be myself and add that to my performance.
From 1972, here's Stevie Wonder's "Superstition."
It is Siobhan Magnus.
# very superstitious #
# writing's on the wall #
# very superstitious #
# ladders about to fall #
# 13-month-old baby #
# broke the lookin' glass #
# seven years of bad luck #
# the good things in your past #
# when you believe in things #
# that you don't understand #
# then you suffer #
# superstition ain't the way #
# very superstitious #
# nothing more to say #
# very superstition #
# the devil's on his way #
# when you believe in things #
# that you don't understand #
# then you suffer #
# superstition ain't the way #
Yo, listen, hey, let me
just tell you, man, I'm always so excited to see you.
Because you're so fearless.
You don't care... I never would
have thought you would have sung that song,
but you know what, I'm telling you, man, I'm happy you did.
I thought it was great.
I loved it, man.
You just went for it and you just go for it.
You've got so much conviction, man.
I love you. You should inspire all these kids.
Thanks.
Oh, Siobhan, to quote Oliver, more, please, more, please.
I just want to see you... You're just so good.
You're so... I just... I love you.
You express yourself every time you perform,
and that's what I love about you,
and I think you're more comfortable there than you are anywhere in your life
and I see that every time.
I don't think it was your best performance,
but I can tell you that end note that you do,
I mean, how do you not say that's amazing,
because it's really ridiculous.
Crazy, crazy, crazy.
Simon?
Yeah, I think there's
going to be a real split with you on this one, Siobhan,
because, you know, some people will like it and I'm afraid a lot of people won't.
and this singing with the screaming at the end is almost
like you've got to reverse it.
Maybe start next week with the screaming at the beginning
and then go softer because it's becoming...
I guess it is your thing,
but I don't think you hit the notes anywhere near
as well as you've done before.
You know, I'm gonna say this to you and
all the contestants really with the exception of one,
which was Crystal tonight,
which I thought was in a different league.
You've got to start pushing
yourselves now and you've got to start finding better songs
and you've got to start making yourselves relevant
because tonight to me was not a good
night overall. Sorry.
Come on over here, Siobhan.
The note... The big note at the end is your favorite part, isn't it?
Yeah, I mean, I can't really
describe the feeling of when I hit those notes,
but, I mean, if I could do a whole song that was those notes...
Simon would love that.
Just scream the whole song.
If you want to vote for Siobhan...
Siobhan, thank you very much.
Good luck to you.
Here are all the numbers one more time.
Take a look at this.
Time to make your choices, friends. A special thanks
to our mentor Miley Cyrus for her help tonight.
Should be performing here tomorrow night.
We'll also have a duet from Demi Lovato and Joe Jonas.
Don't miss it at 9/8 Central.
The lines are open, those stay open at leat two hours.
You gotta vote,to put your favourite into the TOP10 and on the sunmmer tour.
Good luck and good night, America.